Jump to content
DVDVR Message Board

MM16: 3rd RDB - EMMA vs. PENTAGON JR  

106 members have voted

  1. 1. CHOOSE ONE



Recommended Posts

Posted

Well attractive blonde who wrestles - it was as close as I could find to him actually working Emma

Posted

Both of them are very good at what they do. I think Emma's level of difficulty, her improvement, her consistency, and how she has accomplished what she was asked to do puts her over the top. Pentagon has the mask and the facepaint. He has presence, absolutely, but Emma's out there with her past as a bubble-popper Santino buddy, and she's consistently effective in a much more difficult role where she has to balance viciousness, vulnerability, and disdain. There's a lot to what she's doing right now, and she's doing it well, with nuance. Pentagon just doesn't have nearly as complex or complicated a role to play. He's cool, but far more one-dimensional.

Posted

Pentagon lit someone on fire this year. Did Emma? Vote Pentagon.

In my headcanon, she did when she was making her getaway from the great Walmart robbery

I think that was outside the voting period though.

Also, that's how I picture it went down now, too. She's Australian, so it was probably exactly like Mad Max: Fury Road.

Posted

She's willingly dating Zach Ryder. That's got to cost someone some votes.

 

I could post her photos from her vacation with Zack and I am pretty sure that would get her votes back

Posted

Pentagon lit someone on fire this year. Did Emma? Vote Pentagon.

Importantly, it was Vampiro. The only thing better would be if it was Konnan.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Pentagon lit someone on fire this year. Did Emma? Vote Pentagon.

Importantly, it was Vampiro. The only thing better would be if it was Konnan.

 

 

Vampiro is still on my TV screen which means he didn't get the job done

 

Points in Emma's favor

  • Like 1
Posted

She's willingly dating Zach Ryder. That's got to cost someone some votes.

 

I could post her photos from her vacation with Zack and I am pretty sure that would get her votes back

...at the risk of damage to my bracket, I feel we should test this theory.

For science.

Posted

 

 

She's willingly dating Zach Ryder. That's got to cost someone some votes.

 

I could post her photos from her vacation with Zack and I am pretty sure that would get her votes back

 

...at the risk of damage to my bracket, I feel we should test this theory.

For science.

 

 

Emma's Instagram Page

Posted

What's wrong with dating Zach Ryder? He seems like an alright, level-headed guy.

 

It's not like she's dating Mojo.

Posted

Emma's become one of my favourite wrestlers this year. I accept that she may not have the stronger resume but she's been killer on the mic and in segments, great in-ring, and totally unselfish in putting over whoever she's asked in a way that makes them both look good. As I said last match, I don't know if Asuka works without Emma's willingness to be terrified of her the whole way.

Posted

The only stuff I've seen so far from Lucha Underground was an hour long highlight of the Pentagon Jr. story arc from season 1 and the match with Vampiro.

 

So, with that in mind, I'm voting Pentagon. Emma could win some sort of Most Improved competition, but against Pentagon's work as a heel, it just don't rate.

Posted

 

Pentagon lit someone on fire this year. Did Emma? Vote Pentagon.

Importantly, it was Vampiro. The only thing better would be if it was Konnan.

 

 

If you're gonna light an announcer on fire and decide against torching Matt Striker, we've got a serious disconnect. 

  • Like 3
Posted

You guys aren't going on this journey with me, huh?

 

I'm not pushing heavily this round due to tromataker's RL stuff. It feels below the belt. But I do more or less believe what I said above.

Posted

Emma's become one of my favourite wrestlers this year. I accept that she may not have the stronger resume but she's been killer on the mic and in segments, great in-ring, and totally unselfish in putting over whoever she's asked in a way that makes them both look good. As I said last match, I don't know if Asuka works without Emma's willingness to be terrified of her the whole way.

Heh. "Willingness".

Posted

You guys aren't going on this journey with me, huh?

 

I'm not pushing heavily this round due to tromataker's RL stuff. It feels below the belt. But I do more or less believe what I said above.

I will say that his actual matches are the least appealing aspect of Pentagon's game, for me.

 

I don't think he's a bad wrestler by any means, his matches just feel underwhelming in comparison to everything else he does that is awesome.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...