Now I wish I had watched Stargirl. I watched season one then checked out. By the time season one aired, I was mostly checked out of the Berlanti shows. I tended to like season ones a lot, then lose most of my interest thereafter. Supergirl had some good seasons in the middle of its run and Cryer was fantastic late in the series. Only the Covid year (years?) were terrible, imo. I liked Green Arrow but found it repetitious, especially after they expanded the cast.
I still don’t understand Legends appeal. It has a devoted fanbase, so it obviously worked for a lot of people, but it’s one of two shows I’ve legit hated in the past 30 years. Once Darvil left and they leaned into comedy, it was an hour of nails on a chalkboard for me. I kept giving it a try thinking I’d eventually turn the corner on it, but never did.