Please note that Fowler already started the All Elite thread
I don't know if I've seen a Rampage match that would be a 4+ star classic but the guy has good matches with just about everybody. A lot of the better matches of his I've seen are from early days Progress that are on their Demand Progress service. Here he is taking on Ishii in front of a largely dead crowd.
Same thing with Bones/WXW. But here he is wrestling Big Damo/Killian Dain.
Not familiar with Visage or Rockwell though the latter has a great indie gimmick/look: