Jump to content
DVDVR Message Board

February 2023 Wrestling Discussion


Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, Curt McGirt said:

No wonder Heenan had such a low opinion of WCW, imagine walking from Titan's perfectionism straight into that. 

I am trying to do the week by week comparison and watch the corresponding Raw, Superstars, Challenge, and maybe Mania if it's a special episode and not just a PG version Prime Time Wrestling with all the matches from the past week. You can tell Vince micromanages the shit out of everything. Many times, it works. Sometimes, it doesn't especially when you tape the syndicated shows three or four weeks in advance. For example, the 1994 Royal Rumble just passed and Ludvig Borga obviously got replaced by Bam Bam at the PPV against Tatanka. He got hurt at the MSG show (the same show Kid/Jannetty dropped the tag team titles back to the Quebecers) a week or two before the PPV. They NEVER said this dude was not gonna wrestle. Then, the PPV happens and oh yeah Bam Bam is replacing Borga who has an ankle injury. Guess what? Borga shows up on Superstars in two weeks cause they taped it like a week before he got hurt. Whoops. It's his final TV appearance for the WWF, but you would think they would just not air it.

All that said, it's a much tighter ship week to week compared to WCW even with the trial shit going on. I expect it to get interesting though because I don't think we're too far away from Vince hurting his neck and having to miss WWF events for the first time ever. That's how we got Art Donovan and the pile of steaming garbage that was WWF King of the Ring 1994. Also, Hogan signing with WCW is on the horizon.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, GuerrillaMonsoon said:

Been watching the start of WCW Saturday Night from around early 1992.

The K Allen Frey era shits all over the Bill Watts one from a great height, and yet such a discrepancy in praise.

I enjoy a good shitting from a great height every now and again! On Bill Watts? Maybe not.

Edited by Shartnado
Not on the Cowboy!!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, GuerrillaMonsoon said:

I'll throw up a what if.

What if Paul Heyman ends up in the WWF in 1993 rather than booking Eastern Championship Wrestling?

Heyman manages Bigelow since they're friends in real life

Bigelow beats Hogan for the title at King of the Ring 1993 instead of Yokozuna

Bret beats Bam Bam at SummerSlam 1993 by countout

ECW never goes national, Smoky Mountain instead becomes de facto developmental for WWE

Luger never turns face and instead joins Heyman's stable

Bret and Perfect defeat Bam Bam and Luger at Survivor Series 1993

Owen never turns heel

Bret wins Royal Rumble 1994

Shawn-Razor ladder match never happens since Bret vetoes the idea, but the two still feud over the IC title

Bret defeats Bigelow for the title at WrestleMania X after Luger turns on Bam Bam

Perfect wins King of the Ring 1994, turns heel

Bret retains against Perfect at SummerSlam 1994 in a Ladder Match

Edited by Dolphman 3000
  • Like 4
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, GuerrillaMonsoon said:

I'll throw up a what if.

What if Paul Heyman ends up in the WWF in 1993 rather than booking Eastern Championship Wrestling?

ECW never gains any real traction and never becomes the #3 US promotion. probably just becomes another failed regional promotion in a long line of them.

is much else majorly changed? probably not to a huge extent. cruiserweights will still make their way to WCW. Benoit, et. all are probably slightly less featured. the more risque stuff still takes place as Bischoff would still have pushed the envelope to be competitive. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

57 minutes ago, Cobra Commander said:

Imagining the WWE recruitment as being a more upbeat version of the scene where Forrest Gump gets recruited into the military immediately out of college.

“Congratulations, son. Have you given any thought to your future?“

When I read WWE is doing the opposite:

https://youtu.be/CizwH_T7pjg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

would Paul have been on the WWF radar for the "we need an American spokesman for Yokozuna" gig? because that's a scenario which changes things for Paul, ECW, and also maybe for Cornette and Smoky (unless the Bodies get to be in the WWF no matter what)

Considering how meh Dibiase was as a manger, would Paul E have done much more with the Million Dollar Corporation realm of talent?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, GuerrillaMonsoon said:

I'll throw up a what if.

What if Paul Heyman ends up in the WWF in 1993 rather than booking Eastern Championship Wrestling?

I'm still going to the ECW arena every 3 or 4 weeks and JT Smith's championships rival Lawler's Southern title numbers.

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Cobra Commander said:

would Paul have been on the WWF radar for the "we need an American spokesman for Yokozuna" gig? because that's a scenario which changes things for Paul, ECW, and also maybe for Cornette and Smoky (unless the Bodies get to be in the WWF no matter what)

Considering how meh Dibiase was as a manger, would Paul E have done much more with the Million Dollar Corporation realm of talent?

DiBiase was in a weird place, which is why I am surprised it took him until 1996 to wave the white flag. The MDC was basically the job squad save for the 5 weeks Sid was part of the group and the Million Dollar Man character had basically run its course. He notoriously didn't work as a color man in WWF and later on in WCW. Weirdly enough, and I am thinking cause he was a star in the 80s WWF glory days, he got sent to a lot in the charity events they would do. They would send either the Bushwhackers (which would explain why they stuck around forever) or DiBiase or worst case scenario pull one of the boys off the road. 

Heyman would have lifted up to where it didn't feel like a dollar store version of what Jimmy Hart was doing in Memphis w/ the Hart Family. The Million Dollar Corporation felt like if the Hart Family was just Apocalypse (I still need someone to explain wtf he was wearing) and pre MX Bobby Eaton who had to do promos. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just need to know if this hypothetical scenario has 1997/1998 implications for my favorite bad angle: the NWA invasion of WWF.

I mean, if ECW doesn’t happen or have Heyman, then the title being thrown away by Douglas probably doesn’t happen, right? NWA would never be as big as it was, but that effectively killed them.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Based on his history w/ WCW and later on with WWE, I think Heyman manages to find a way to get himself fired from WWF. So you might have a weird butterfly effect where ECW doesn't get hot for awhile and then by the time if takes off, the MNW is in full effect. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Does the MNW even happen if there's not a significant third promotion for most of these guys? Does Austin end up on the radar without the ECW stint? Does Foley continue working Japan/money mark independents instead? Does WCW have the roster to justify the second hour of Nitro without Benoit/Guerrero/Malenko/Jericho/Rey/Psicosis being as well known as they were?

Is there that much of a counter-culture that actively protests against the Hogan superhero babyface that warrants the need for Hogan to turn heel?

 

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, GuerrillaMonsoon said:

Does the MNW even happen if there's not a significant third promotion for most of these guys?

Yes, but I feel that someone would have picked up the slack. There was just too much talent out there.

Quote

Does Austin end up on the radar without the ECW stint? Does Foley continue working Japan/money mark independents instead? Does WCW have the roster to justify the second hour of Nitro without Benoit/Guerrero/Malenko/Jericho/Rey/Psicosis being as well known as they were?

Is there that much of a counter-culture that actively protests against the Hogan superhero babyface that warrants the need for Hogan to turn heel?

Austin was supposedly already on WWF's radar by the time he got to ECW, which is why his run did not last more than a few months. Yeah, Foley does indies/Japan but JR/Cornette would have eventually brought him in or at least worn Vince down enough into bringing him. As for the other guys, the guys from Mexico probably end up going up in American indies if someone doesn't snatch them up right away. Going back to first point, if AAA doesn't expand outside of SoCal/San Jose/Chicago for the run of shows they did in 93/94, someone eventually does it with that crew. Art Barr dying throws a monkey wrench into no matter what. So does the peso crashing, but you can still do a heavily skewed Latin market based super indy. Jericho was already on the American radar. So was Benoit, who already worked in WCW multiple times prior to ECW and had great showings.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would they have been as reliable as Heyman and willing to promote a product that catered to numerous demographics? Everyone else at the time were the erratic cokeheads like Herb Abrams, Joel Goodhart etc, or guys like Cornette and Corraluzzo who just wanted to produce throwback shows for their own enjoyment. Throw in between a series of money marks who didn't have the connections or expertise to run shows frequently enough or sustainably. 

Also difficult to consider where Memphis fits in here, given they were propped up by Vince just as much as Heyman and Cornette were.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...