While I think Rotten Tomatoes is pretty good way to determine quality on a current movie (although not always), I find their older movie reviews (or lack thereof) to usually be off the mark. Deadly Friend, while not a great horror movie, is far from bottom of the rung when it comes to the genre.
That said, I stumbled into this forum and I think has given me an excuse to pull out some horror films and go through them. I have a ton already in mind, but look forward to rewatching and finding some new ones. I would probably vote depending on my enjoyment of the movie rather than whether it